Osaka YMCA
International School

collaboration science
Joy Biswas

Joy Biswas

Joy Biswas is the MYP Science and DP Chemistry teacher at OYIS. Originally from India, he has lived and taught before in China, Zimbabwe and the US. He enjoys cooking and playing bridge.

The group 4 project is an interdisciplinary activity in which all Diploma Programme science students must participate. The intention is that students from the different group 4 subjects (Physics, Chemistry and Biology) analyse a common topic or problem. The exercise is meant to be a collaborative experience where the emphasis is on the processes involved in, rather than the products of, such an activity.

Collaboration in STEM

Growing up in India, one of the central events in Hinduism and an oft-repeated fable for children, is the churning of the ocean of milk between two groups of natural enemies; the devas (gods) and the asuras (demons, or titans). The devas, who had become weakened, as a result of a curse, used the asuras greed to help them recover the elixir of immortality, the amrita, from the depths of the cosmic ocean. When the amrita appeared, the gods and the asuras fought over its possession, though they had originally agreed to share it equally. Here is a rock sculpture of the same from the famous Angkor Vat in Laos, Cambodia.

Churning of the Ocean

The Latin verb collaborare which means to work together with others, is the root of the word collaboration. However, working together could mean very different things depending on the field in which the action takes place. To collaborate in a musical orchestra is not the same as to collaborate in a cricket team. The initial point might be the same – people working together – but then everything changes: the number of people in the team, task organization, the scope they have to fulfill. As a matter of fact, collaboration is much more than a plural number of people working together. It is a complex process whose features and functions vary dramatically not only from field to field but also from case to case.

According to Y. N. Harari, the first achievement toward scientific progress was a collective admission of ignorance. By agreeing on the fact that humans do not hold the answers to fundamental questions, true seekers as a whole felt the urge to fill the gap: “Modern-day science is a unique tradition of knowledge inasmuch as it openly admits collective ignorance regarding the most important questions.” (Harari, 2011: 279–281).

The argument here is that interdisciplinary collaboration is a prerequisite for science to contribute to solving problems and bring about an impact of knowledge (Tromp, 2018). Menken & Keestra (2016, p. 34) put it briefly and to the point: complexity is “the main driving force behind interdisciplinarity.”
Interdisciplinary science problems

The term “discipline” is related to the Latin disciplina, which means education, science, rules and fundamental principles, as well as giving instructions to a disciple. “Disciplines discipline disciples” (Barry & Born, 2013b, p. 1). Chettiparamb (2007) states that the Oxford English Dictionary records the word originated in the Middle Ages but that the origin of disciplines as a way of organizing academia varies geographically and depends on the type of discipline.

The growth of scientific disciplines can also be seen as a process of differentiation in society, in which new, independent communication systems are created. Each individual discipline is embedded in an internal environment of other disciplines. The constant, mutual observation and interaction of these disciplines is the most important factor in the dynamics of modern science.

In education, a distinction can be made between four levels of interdisciplinarity (Klein, 1990, p. 57) that are found in practice:

1. Students take a selection of courses from different departments;
2. The academic institution provides opportunity for students to share insights from various disciplinary courses;
3. Courses are aimed at an interdisciplinary subject, in which various schools or faculty members participate;
4. There is a conscious attempt to integrate material and methodologies from various fields of knowledge into a new, single, intellectually coherent entity and build a common vocabulary.

Today, as in the past, liberal arts colleges have the most striking interdisciplinary programs, for which there is a great deal of interest. Bachelor’s programs such as Liberal Arts & Sciences showed that, annually, 2000 students enroll for the small-scale Liberal Arts programs. The rise of modern liberal arts colleges is seen as the turning point at which interdisciplinarity develops or evolves in response to the dominance of disciplinarity.

CERN: A Mega Science Collaborative Project

CERN, an acronym for Consiel Européen pour la Recherche Nucléaire, is an intergovernmental organization founded with the prime aim of performing fundamental research in nuclear physics. It hosts the world’s most powerful particle accelerator, the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), which makes protons and ions collide in four points of its 27 km circular tunnel.
Of the 20,000 people that globally work together on projects in CERN, only 2500 are employed directly by CERN. The remaining members are affiliated with institutes in more than 70 countries, for a total of 110 nationalities.
A big community such as this is organized in two interrelated categories: Experiments and Collaborations. The biggest Experiments at the four colliding points of the accelerator (named ALICE, ATLAS, CMS and LHCb) come with Collaborations that number 1500 to 8000 people, including scientists, engineers, technicians and administrative personnel. The aspiration of these Collaborations is to help in answering fundamental questions like what is the Universe made of and what keeps it together. The investigation begins with what might be termed a creative step: deciding which kind of experimental steps to pursue and defining directions to do so, but will only remain the stuff of dreams unless there is a global collaboration of scientists.

OYIS, IB and the Group 4 Project

As is mentioned on the website, Osaka YMCA International School (OYIS) is built around the concept of community where all stakeholders strive to support students using the principles of Encounter, Connect and Transform. At the heart of this vision lies the skill of collaboration. MYP students recently showcased this when carrying out their Interdisciplinary units in the MYP.

IB Diploma students are required to choose at least one Science ‘discipline’ at the beginning of their Grade 11 journey. In IB jargon, Science is categorized as Group 4. One of the requirements for the successful completion of their choice of science course(s) is the collaborative Group 4 project.

As per the IB subject guide for the sciences, the group 4 project is an interdisciplinary activity in which all Diploma Programme science students must participate. The intention is that students from the different group 4 subjects (Physics, Chemistry and Biology) analyse a common topic or problem. The exercise is meant to be a collaborative experience where the emphasis is on the processes involved in, rather than the products of, such an activity. Here is an example of a Group 4 project from Yokohama International School, Japan:

The group 4 project is a collaborative activity where students from different group 4 subjects work together on a scientific or technological topic, allowing for concepts and perceptions from across the disciplines to be shared in line with the IB Sciences aims, specifically to develop and apply 21st century communication skills in the study of science, become critically aware, as global citizens, of the ethical implications of using science and technology and to develop an understanding of the relationships between scientific disciplines and their influence on other areas of knowledge”. This Group 4 project for OYIS students will be carried out in June and involves the following stages:


This stage must involve all group 4 students meeting to “brainstorm” and discuss the central topic, sharing ideas and information. After selecting a topic or issue, the activities to be carried out must be clearly defined before moving from the planning stage to the action and evaluation stages.


Students should investigate the topic in mixed-subject groups or single subject groups. There should be collaboration during the action stage; findings of investigations should be shared with other students within the mixed/single-subject group.


The emphasis during this stage is on students sharing their findings, both successes and failures, with other students. How this is achieved can be decided by the teachers, the students or jointly, usually through a symposium or group presentations.

We are very excited to see this entire collaborative process unfold and our students encounter a challenging theme, connect with students from other science subjects and transform their understanding about the topic and the world through the scientific method.


  1. Harari Y. N. (2011). Sapiens: a Brief history of humankind. New York, NY: Harper.
  2. Tromp, C. (2018), Wicked Philosophy. Philosophy of science and vision development for complex problems. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
  3. Menken, S. & M. Keestra (eds.) (2016), An Introduction to Interdisciplinary Research Theory and Practice. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
  4. Brewer, G. D. (1999), The Challenges of Interdisciplinarity. Policy Sciences, 32, 327-337.
  5. Hoffmann-Riem, H., Biber-Klemm, S., Grossenbacher-Mansuy, W., Hirsch Hadorn, G., Joye, D., Pohl, C., Wiesmann, U., Zemp, E., (2008), Handbook of Transdisciplinary Research.
  6. Barry, A. & Born, G., (2013a), Interdisciplinarity: Reconfigurations of the social and natural sciences. London and New York: Routledge.
  7. Chettiparamb, A., (2007), Interdisciplinarity: a literature review, The Interdisciplinary Teaching and Learning Group, Subject Centre for Languages, Linguistics and Area Studies, School of Humanities, University of Southampton.
  8. Klein, J.T. (1990), Interdisciplinarity. History, Theory & Practice. Detroit: Wayne State University Press.
  9. Adler, M. & Flihan, S., (1997), The interdisciplinary continuum: reconciling theory, research and practice. National Research Center on English Learning & Achievement, University at Albany, State University of New York,
  10. Accessed 2022-03-26 11:43pm
  11. IB Chemistry subject Guide (2016), Group 4 project, 185-187

Share this post

Leave a Reply

School Blog

What Makes an IB School Different?

One of the most popular questions I am asked by parents is ‘what makes an IB school different from other schools?
Firstly, IB schools specifically aim to make students more internationally-minded. That may sound like a cliche, so let’s explore what it really means.

Read More »

WASC Praises Osaka School

The Western Association of Schools and Colleges (WASC) recently completed an evaluation of Osaka YMCA International School (OYIS). It found that measures were in place to support inclusive education and ensure that each child meets his or her potential. OYIS has been praised for being ‘caring’ and committed to achieving high standards.

OYIS is an IB continuum school, which means it offers an IB curriculum throughout the whole school, from the Primary Years Programme (PYP) through to the Middle Years Programme (MYP) and the IB Diploma in Grades 11 and 12.nWASC recognised that growth in PYP was above average while the MYP Maths’ scores were particularly impressive.

Despite the challenges all schools have faced during the pandemic, WASC found that the school had been seen as being ‘caring’ and ‘flexible’ during these times.

OYIS, which has campuses in Nakatsu and Tosabori, aims to be inclusive and support each child’s needs. WASC also recognized this, saying it was a significant area of growth. With the school’s first-ever IB Diploma students preparing to graduate this year, WASC felt the college guidance program was developing well.

PYP Principal Dwayne Primeau said: “We work very hard to ensure that we build a school culture that is inclusive, caring and welcoming. The school has expanded rapidly over the past few years due to the support of the Osaka YMCA, Osaka city, our amazing staff, students and parents. It is reassuring to hear that WASC feels we are continuing to move in the right direction to provide a truly international education to our students.”

MYP/DP Principal Mark Beales added: “It was pleasing to hear that WASC recognized the significant amount of work teachers have put in over the past few years. As well as meeting the challenges of covid, the school has expanded to include the MYP and IB Diploma. We are delighted that WASC praised our caring and empathetic approach to helping students; we will continue to promote these qualities.”

Read More »

Osaka Students can sit SATs

Students in Osaka City are now able to take internationally-recognized tests as they prepare for university.
Osaka YMCA International School (OYIS) has just been given permission to host Scholastic Assessment Tests (SAT).

Read More »
School Blog

The Choices We Make: Building School Community

It was my goal that OYIS would be a safe space for young people and would aim to provide a community where they felt safe, supported, and engaged. I wanted to build a space where I would have felt connected to and supported.

Read More »






Add Your Heading Text Here